Minoan Frescoes: Conservation Techniques and Compositions

Bull Leaping Fresco
Bull Leaping Fresco

Discovered over a century ago, the Bull-Leaping Fresco has been extensively studied and theorized about by many art historians and archeologists. It allows us to glean information on the way frescoes were made, along with the techniques used on frescoes and wall art captured by Hugh Sackett, this being conservational or original work.

Known to be made of plaster and originally thought as archaic Greek due to their excavation from prehistoric floors (Shaw 174), the Bull-Leaping Fresco is also telling of the techniques used by the artist. According to Maria C. Shaw, when studying the bulls and leapers of Fresco No. 5, "given the superposition of several pigments... [and the fact that] they still adhere to the successive painted surfaces relatively well... suggests that the artist was working at some speed" (Shaw 175). Speed which, contrasted by the discovered traces of an ochre yellow outline, becomes a contradictory practice. Frescoes naturally require speed from the artist since it is a technique that uses a wet surface and wet paint. However, the ochre yellow tracings demonstrate another kind of artistic inclination, one towards calm and a steady pace. The underlying outline demonstrates the artist's attention to detail, towards a meticulous process which precisely takes care of compositional errors and involves planning out the entire compositional drawing of the fresco. This is of course for the original technique used to make the fresco.

On the other hand, archeologists and art historians had the job to assemble the pieces and fill in the gaps of what was left behind at the Palace of Knossos. Reconstructions and conservation efforts like this will be further discussed in the following pieces photographed by Sackett.


 

Knossos  '60 Bull Fresco
Knossos '60 Bull Fresco

To continue on the analysis of bull frescoes, relief frescoes were common when treating this significant symbol in Minoan frescoes. Moreover, this specific relief fresco is noted by Sackett as a reconstruction, over a reconstructed porch. And it is recognized as so by many modern scholars as well. In fact, the bull-relief photographed by Sackett, is known as the charging bull fresco of the Knossos North Entrance. It is also noted by scholars, the significance of said reconstruction, not only to preserve and revive an ancient site, but for the actual purposes of studying it in scholarly practice. Scholars say, "except for the rebuilt portico containing the relief fresco of the charging bull" ... there are "no very good plans of the whole area" (Woodard, pg.113). The lack of good study plans of the Palace of Knossos is commented on by various scholars and demonstrates the importance of reconstruction and restoration in archeological sites.

dolphin fresco
Dolphin Fresco of the Queen's Megaron at Knossos

Located at the Palace of Minos in the room known as the Queen's Megaron, the Dolphin Fresco lays overhead the double-door frame. As some sources specify, this pleasant wall painting was a reconstruction of the original work. It is important to mention that the original remains of the fresco are on display and restored in the Heraklion Museum but here are some notable differences. Opposed to the reconstruction inside the Palace, the restoration in the Museum only features two of the dolphins and 13 smaller fish (Koehl, pg.407). This again, helps the viewer understand the difference between restoration and reconstruction, important in the study of art history, here through the lenses of Hugh Sackett.

ladies
Reproduction of the "Ladies in Blue" fresco, ca. 1525-1450 B.C., Painted Plaster, Late Minoan IB, Restored in 1927

The "Ladies in Blue '' Fresco was first excavated before 1914 near Royal Magazines in Knossos. The composition depicts three women that although could be argued Minoan due to their open-chest garments and traditional colors used, debates arise when there is restoration involved. In an article published by the Metropolitan Museum of Art, it was argued by the writer Evelyn Waugh, that by looking at this fresco "it is not easy to judge the merits of Minoan painting". The writer makes this argument due to the presence of virtually minimal original fresco after extensive restoration done by Emile Guillieron. More when the restorations are something so fitting to today's aesthetic standards. And just how Waugh mentions seemingly an "inappropriate predilection for the covers of Vogue".

Here I want to highlight the restoration techniques used to preserve frescoes which both art historians and archeologists ought to keep in mind when dealing with excavated material such as that photographed by Hugh Sackett.

Conservational studies here give archeological findings an interesting spin. By conservational chemical  analysis, scholars have been able to identify details which help further understand the gaps created in restored work, and why writers such as Waugh think that heavily restored works lose their merits to be judged and considered part of scholarly material.

Scholars mention that in the scientific analysis of Minoan Frescoes at Knossos, samples of pigments were taken, and two types of blue were found incorporated in the frescoes. The mentioned colors were first a sky-blue color consisting of small blue crystals. The pigment had "a high copper content and was identified as Egyptian blue" (Cameron, Jones, Philippakis, pg. 140). On the other hand, the second color had large dark blue crystals that correlate with the presence of a high concentration of iron identified as riebeckite.  Frescoes had fluctuating concentrations of both types of blue which eventually made the frescoes distinct in composition compared to their seemingly equal restoration pieces.

This detail however, demonstrates the importance of conservation practices that come with the analysis of the ancient colors. Detail that in itself cannot be left out of the studies of the techniques used in the conservation efforts of Minoan frescoes.

Knossos '60 South Entrance Cup Bearer Fresco
Knossos '60 South Entrance Cup Bearer Fresco
Knossos South Entrance
Knossos South Entrance

Finally,  an examination of conservation practices on minoan frescoes could not be complete without the mention of Sir Arthur Evans and his reconstructions made of the throne room and the South Entrance of the Palace (Hopkins pg. 416). Or those of Mark Cameron on the Cup bearer frescoes (Hood, pg.45). Both scholars made a huge contribution to the conservation and restoration practices thanks to which we are today allowed to study the splendid Minoan frescoes.